Santa Cruz County is home to some of the best cinnamon rolls on the California coast, with bakeries and cafés crafting these sweet treats to perfection. Whether you prefer them sticky and caramelized, loaded with cinnamon, or topped with a rich cream cheese frosting, there’s no shortage of places to satisfy your craving. From cozy local bakeries to well-loved institutions, we’ve rounded up the top spots where you can find the most irresistible cinnamon rolls in Santa Cruz County.
Busy Bees Cafe & Catering
Busy Bees Café is a hidden gem in Capitola, serving up some of the most indulgent cinnamon rolls in the county. These cinnamon rolls are warmed to perfection and full of rich flavor. Each roll is generously sized, with a velvety, gooey cinnamon filling and a thick layer of icing that melts into the warm pastry. The texture is pillowy soft, making each bite a sweet, satisfying treat. This hidden gem spot is also one of the best places in town to grab a breakfast burrito. Whether enjoyed fresh on the café’s sunny patio, accompanied by a hot cup of coffee, or taken to the beach for a sweet seaside indulgence, these cinnamon rolls are the highlight of any morning. A visit to Busy Bees Café isn’t complete without one, and once you’ve tried it, you’ll find it hard to resist coming back for more.
Companion Bakeshop
Companion Bakeshop has earned its reputation for some of the best bread and pastries in town, and their cinnamon rolls are no exception. If you’re a fan of a cinnamon roll with a twist, their version is a must-try. Made with sourdough, these rolls offer a subtle tang that beautifully complements the rich, caramelized cinnamon filling. Not overly sweet, they strike the perfect balance for those who appreciate a more nuanced flavor profile. The dough has exceptional structural integrity, with a slight crunch on the outside that contrasts perfectly with the soft, gooey interior. Topped with just the right amount of frosting, each bite is a delightful experience. Each roll is crafted with locally sourced ingredients and an undeniable commitment to quality. Companion Bakeshop’s cinnamon rolls are a standout choice for anyone seeking a unique yet satisfying treat.
The Buttery
A Santa Cruz institution, The Buttery is known for its delectable pastries, and their cinnamon rolls are a true highlight. These rolls are large, fluffy, and perfectly spiced, with a balanced cinnamon-sugar filling that melts into the soft dough. You can get your cinnamon roll with or without raisins, which sets this spot apart from the other locations. The light icing is perfect for those looking for a treat that isn’t too sweet or rich. The bready texture makes the cinnamon roll feel so soft and pull-apart perfect!
Gayle’s Bakery & Rosticceria
Gayle’s Bakery is a local favorite for a reason, and their cinnamon rolls showcase their expertise in crafting irresistible pastries. Their old fashioned cinnamon rolls will transport you to a rich and decadent past that is equal parts nostalgic and delicious. This cinnamon roll is definitely for the sweets lover! The thick, creamy icing is like a dreamy cloud of sweetness. The texture is similar to that of a donut and is incredibly soft! Big enough to share, Gayle’s cinnamon rolls are a real star in their already impressive line up of baked goods.
Seabreeze Cafe
A cozy brunch favorite near the Santa Cruz Harbor, Linda’s Seabreeze Café serves up cinnamon rolls that feel homemade in the best way. These rolls are soft, buttery, and packed with cinnamon goodness. Their cinnamon roll is layered with walnuts and cinnamon sugar without icing, making it perfect for those who want a less sweet option. Many of Seabreeze Cafe’s great breakfast dishes come served with a cinnamon roll or order it al a carte with a coffee for the perfect treat!
This list only scratches the surface of the excellent bakeries in our area making delicious cinnamon rolls and other exquisite pastries. If you’re gluten free, check out Melinda’s Gluten Free Bakery for cinnamon rolls as well!